Drag to compare 
13 pairs 7 brands
Shingle Comparison, Head to Head.
Shingle comparison across 13 pairs of the brands and lines shopped most. Drag any pair to move between the two lines on comparable houses, then read the spec table underneath.
Most shopped
Compare roofing shingles, brand against brand.
Sorted by search popularity, so the highest-interest comparisons surface first. Every pair is on this page — jump straight to one, or scroll the lot.
13 shingle comparisons, most-shopped first.
13 head-to-head comparisons across the seven major asphalt shingle brands. Every page has the same shape: a draggable visual comparison at the top, a spec table with real numbers in every cell, a decision rubric, install pricing context from Florida contractors, and verified quotes from r/Roofing. Sorted by search popularity so the highest-interest comparisons surface first.
CertainTeed Landmark vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Category
CertainTeed Landmark
GAF Timberline HDZ
Material cost / square
$135-145
$132-140
Weight per square
230 lbs
240 lbs
Wind rating
110 mph (base) / 130 mph upgrade
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
GAF Timberline HDZ vs Owens Corning Duration
Category
GAF Timberline HDZ
Owens Corning Duration
Material cost / square
$132-140
$140-150
Weight per square
240 lbs
230 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
CertainTeed Landmark vs CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Category
CertainTeed Landmark
CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Material cost / square
$135-145
$165-185
Weight per square
230 lbs
270 lbs
Wind rating
110 mph (base) / 130 mph upgrade
110 mph (base) / 130 mph upgrade
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
GAF Timberline UHDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Category
GAF Timberline UHDZ
CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Material cost / square
$175-195
$165-185
Weight per square
~280 lbs
~270 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
110 / 160 upgrade
Hail / impact
Class 4
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Category
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine
GAF Timberline HDZ
Material cost / square
$130-140
$132-140
Weight per square
~225 lbs
~240 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
IKO Cambridge vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Category
IKO Cambridge
GAF Timberline HDZ
Material cost / square
$110-125
$132-140
Weight per square
215 lbs
240 lbs
Wind rating
110-130 mph
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
TAMKO Heritage vs IKO Cambridge
Category
TAMKO Heritage
IKO Cambridge
Material cost / square
$95-115
$90-110
Weight per square
~210 lbs
~210 lbs
Wind rating
110 mph
110 mph / 130 upgrade
Hail / impact
Class 3 optional
Class 3 optional
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Malarkey Legacy vs Owens Corning Duration
Category
Malarkey Legacy
Owens Corning Duration
Material cost / square
$145-160
$135-150
Weight per square
~250 lbs
~230 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 4
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Owens Corning Duration vs CertainTeed Landmark
Category
Owens Corning Duration
CertainTeed Landmark
Material cost / square
$140-150
$135-145
Weight per square
230 lbs
230 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
110 mph (base) / 130 mph upgrade
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
CertainTeed Grand Manor vs IKO Royal Estate
Category
CertainTeed Grand Manor
IKO Royal Estate
Material cost / square
$315-360
$230-265
Weight per square
470 lbs
270 lbs
Wind rating
110 / 130 upgrade
110 / 130 upgrade
Hail / impact
Class 4
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Malarkey Vista AR vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Category
Malarkey Vista AR
GAF Timberline HDZ
Material cost / square
$165-200
$132-140
Asphalt type
NEX polymer-modified (rubberized SBS)
Standard fiberglass-asphalt
Wind rating
110 mph base / 130 mph enhanced
130 mph + WindProven unlimited
Hail / impact
Class 4
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Timberline Slate vs Pewter Gray
Category
Timberline Slate
Pewter Gray
Material cost / square
$137-157
$137-157
Color hex
#5c635c
#585b5e
Undertone
Green
Neutral
Wind rating
Up to 150 mph
Up to 150 mph
Warranty
30 years
30 years
Owens Corning Duration vs Owens Corning Duration Designer
Category
Owens Corning Duration
Owens Corning Duration Designer
Material cost / square
$140-150
$165-185
Weight per square
230 lbs
250 lbs
Wind rating
130 mph
130 mph
Hail / impact
Class 3
Class 3
Fire rating
Class A
Class A
Material cost per square · Florida contractor pricing · verify before you order · the dot on each slider label is the manufacturer hex
Not sure what is on your roof today? Start with the address.
Type your street address
For example: 24500 SW Kanner Hwy, Stuart FL
Not sure of the exact address? Browse by city instead
See any pair on your house.
A spec table settles the warranty and the wind rating. It cannot tell you which one looks right on your street.